To print: Click here or Select File and then Print from your browser's menu
Sharing Your Drawings: An Introduction to Collaboration
by: Bill Burchard
URL: http://pointa.autodesk.com/gotoPointA.jsp?dest=15820
Designers have always collaborated, but nowadays they do it digitally rather than on paper. That's great. Paper is dumb, unlike digital designs, and contains neither object properties nor historical intelligence. Even so, electronic data presents other collaborative obstacles that must be considered and overcome.

This overview is the first in a series that examines both the history and current state of collaboration tools and techniques, as well as the latest collaboration innovations.

In the Beginning
If you've been around long enough, you saw the advent of CAD. So you're sure to recall the 5 ¼" floppies (about ¾ MB) and 3 ½" floppies (about 1 ½ MB) that even "way back when" proved too small for sharing CAD drawings effectively.

Of course, you could—just—transfer a single, large drawing file onto multiple floppies (a process called spanning), but managing and tracking those floppies was a headache. And retrieving the file from the disks was an even larger headache. And heaven help you if you didn't properly record the sequential order of the floppies, or worse yet, lost one of the disks.

The introduction of CDs changed much of that, overcoming the serious storage limitations of floppies. As time went by, the cost for both CD burners and the disks dropped dramatically, making CDs a viable and relatively inexpensive medium for sharing files. You still have to manage and track disks of course. And CD distribution still has the same old drawbacks—whether the disk has to get across town or halfway round the world, it takes time, sometimes lots of time, to complete the journey.

Networking with Others
CDs haven't gone the way of floppies—yet. But they may. Networked computers and the broad acceptance of the Internet have made it even easier for designers to share their data with others. In a networked environment, by mapping logical drives to shared folders on servers or workstations, team members can quickly access a file, either copying it to their local system or directly working on it from the mapped drive. Of course, this method of sharing files also presents management challenges. How do you limit file access to only authorized users (a security issue)? How do you manage and track a file's revision history to ensure that users don't accidentally overwrite the current drawing version with an outdated copy or simply misplace the current drawing in the wrong folder?


 

FTPing
Another widely used tool for sharing electronic data is File Transfer Protocol (FTP), which is the direct transfer of files from one computer to another. Available since the 70s, FTP is still the standard for file transfers over the Internet. It is simple to use and is platform independent, meaning you can transfer files to any operating system, from Windows to Macintosh to Unix.

FTP has several advantages over disks for sharing design data:

  • FTP does not have the file size limitation of floppies or CDs.
  • Data transfer typically takes seconds or a few minutes, unlike disks which can take days.
  • You can share your design data with anyone, anywhere in the world so long as they have access to a modem.
  • Since FTP acts as a repository for files, disparate team members can download shared files at their convenience.
  • A single file can be shared with multiple team members by simply providing each team member with access privileges.
  • FTP adds a level of security because access is limited to those having proper authorizations.

Internet, Intranets, and Extranets
As the world has become more connected via the Internet, intranets, and extranets, other forms of sharing data have been introduced and gained in popularity. Probably the most popular method for sharing electronic design data these days is through e-mail. Virtually every company and every CAD user has an e-mail address. Sharing design data this way is as easy as 1-2-3. Type up a short electronic note about a file you wish to share, attach the file to your e-mail, and send it off to the recipient. In a matter of seconds, the file appears in the recipient's mailbox, ready to download and open. As long as team members have high-speed Internet connections (something much more common today than just a few years ago), sharing even large drawing files is easy and fast.

But you still have to manage those e-mailed drawing files. Tracking who sent which files to whom can quickly become a management nightmare if proper file transfer procedures aren't in place and enforced. Given that e-mail is so easy to use for sharing files, you might be lulled into sending files the moment someone requests them and fail to properly record the transaction. By not properly recording the date and time the file is sent and to whom, or the condition of the file (was it only 50 percent complete?), you may end up releasing inaccurate, outdated, incomplete files to unsuspecting team members. Worse yet, if checks and balances are not in place, you might even up sending files to requestors that should not be given access to the files in the first place. Good-bye security.

Many firms have in place, or are preparing, in-house procedures for sharing design files over e-mail. With proper management—typically in the form of IT staff—firms are tracking who has their files, as well as the percent-complete condition of the files. That means the project team can better coordinate their efforts, and it ensures that only the correct and appropriate files are shared.

Hosted Project Websites
Given that providing IT personnel is not always an option, other firms are using hosted websites to garner the same benefits. Project-hosting services can minimize the day-to-day IT support operations from the project team's perspective, allowing team members to focus on the design project. Collaborating via a hosted website provides a convenient and secure method for managing, tracking, and sharing electronic design data.

Summary
Autodesk has developed a variety of solutions that meet the challenges of managing, tracking, securing, and sharing electronic design data over the Internet, intranets, extranets, and via e-mail. In the next two articles, we'll explore some of these solutions in more detail. Most of you are ready for real-time electronic design collaboration, which these solutions enable, although most of us still have a fondness for the paper-based designs we grew up with.

 


Bill Burchard is Corporate CADD Manager for Psomas, a California-based land surveying and civil engineering firm. He is also an Autodesk Registered Author who has written and co-authored numerous books including AutoCAD 2002: Migration Manual, AutoCAD 2002: Professional, AutoCAD 2002: Complete, and Inside AutoCAD 2002. In addition, Bill writes for CADALYST magazine, sits on the Advisory Committee Board for Computer Sciences at Riverside Community College, and lectures on GIS at the University of California, Irvine. He can be reached at bill@billburchard.com. His Web site is BillBurchard.com.